Return on Equity and Debt Leverage (2023)

Construction contracting is a risky business that should yield appropriate returns. We did this fun comparison looking at different types of contractor's financial benchmark returns and debt leverage against some selected other companies for 2023.

D. Brown Management Profile Picture
Share

 

 

We recently conducted this exercise for fun to compare construction contractor benchmarks against other types of businesses to assess risks and returns. This is a simple comparison focusing on two financial metrics: Return-on-Equity (Operating Profits / Total Equity) and Debt-to-Equity (Total Liabilities / Total Equity). 

Consider the true risk of each business in the comparison. Is construction contracting more or less risky than oil & gas? Retail? Restaurants? Manufacturing?

On average, construction contractors achieve a Return-on-Equity of 30%, with General Building Contractors averaging slightly higher at 40% due to the additional leverage of subcontracted work. Keep in mind that these are averages, meaning some contractors are losing money at one end of the bell curve, while others are achieving double the returns shown above at the other end. 

Where would your business place on this matrix over the last three years? 

 

Note that you have higher leverage on some businesses due to the high capital investments required for manufacturing (Ford / CAT), while others have been through some re-engineering processes that included increasing debt leverage, like Darden Restaurants. Others, like Google, are holding on to cash to fund future growth, which lowers their returns when only looking at these metrics but keeps their market valuation high because shareholders are expecting that cash to be put to use for both organic and acquisition-based growth. 

Remember that while you can use debt to increase Return-on-Equity, as shown in the example below, it can also hinder long-term resiliency.

 

 

Debt can be an amazing partner in good times but quickly turns into a relentless enemy during bad times. 

 

You probably didn't get into The Business of Building because you loved finance. Don't hesitate to contact us to discuss your specific situation, including how to best align your capital and talent for the best returns. 

 

Learn a little more with:

 

 

 

 



Related Training

Capital Constraints to Growth (The Basic Formula)
Capital is one of the three primary growth constraints for construction contractors. Use this simple formula to determine how much of your pre-tax net profits need to be retained in the company to support growth and to establish your safe growth limits.
Integrating Constraints and Strategic Targets
Available talent, capital, and work in the market are the basic constraints every contractor must work within. Understanding and managing all three better each year is the foundation of sustainable growth.
Return on Working Capital (Project Level)
Reduce risk and increase returns by analyzing opportunities and selecting those that offer the highest return on working capital.