Higher Scores Aren’t Always Better: Percent Planned Complete (PPC) Example

Construction is full of competitive personalities - more is always better. This is not always the case, and you must be careful when setting targets that your goals don't have unintended consequences. Percent Planned Complete (PPC) is a perfect example.

Joseph Irby Profile Picture
Joseph Irby
February 4, 2024 2 minute read
lean construction
Share

 

Article Image

 

Percent Planned Complete (PPC) is a critical measure of a weekly work plan or SIP (Short-Interval Plan). 

David MacNeel from On Point Lean describes that higher scores aren't always better in this interview with Felipe Engineer-Manriquez on the EBFC (Easier, Better, for Construction) Show (4 minutes starting at 0:20:00)

 

 

54% was the average amount of weekly tasks that got completed as planned when Greg Howell and Glenn Ballard first studied the problem in the late 90s. 

Low to Mid 70s: Likely on-track with schedule and productivity (Two Key Results for Project Planning)

High 70s to High 80s: Likely ahead of schedule and productivity targets. 

High 80s to Low 90s: Great team and conditions.

Mid to High 90s: Likely gaming the system - sandbagging or misreporting. 

 

An important part of your scorekeeping process is setting appropriate targets with tolerances and clear management escalations if there are large variances, or they are trending in the wrong direction for too long. 

 

Related Training
Muhammad Ali - Pebble in the Shoe
Construction contracting is largely a game of operational excellence. Between the massive changes going on in the industry and daily operations it is easy for leaders and their teams to overlook the small opportunities for improvement every day.
Related Article
Lean Principle - People First (Then Process and Tools)
To optimize productivity, a contractor must focus on their people first, then processes and tools including technology as an integrated management system with a hierarchy. This is not a linear process: S.M.A.R.T. Experiments + Continuous Improvement.
Related Article
Lean Principle - Observation (Gemba Walks and Learning to See)
One of the most important tools for improving productivity is going to the jobsite or work area and observing for an extended period of time with the intent to understand but not to immediately interact. Observation progresses through about 7 stages.
Related Article